For legal professionals · Personal injury & clinical negligencesimpsonmedicolegal@gmail.com

Simpson Medicolegal Services

Peripheral nerve
expert witness.

Independent medical evidence in peripheral nerve injury, brachial plexus injury and upper limb orthopaedic surgery.

Mr Ashley Simpson provides specialist opinion for personal injury and clinical negligence matters, accepting Claimant, Defendant and Joint instructions.

28days

Report turnaroundWithin 28 days of assessment, or receipt of documentation for a desktop report.

Mr Ashley Simpson, Consultant Peripheral Nerve Surgeon, in black surgical scrubs
Mr Ashley SimpsonConsultant Peripheral Nerve SurgeonBA(Hons) · MBBS · MSc · MA(Cantab) · PGCME · PGCert (Data Science)
FRCS (Orth) · FAcadMEd
Simpson Medicolegal Services
Simpson Medicolegal Services

An independent opinion

Clinical evidence.
Clearly explained.

Opinions are grounded in the clinical evidence and confined to matters within Mr Simpson’s expertise. Material uncertainties, alternative explanations and limitations of the available evidence are identified.

When providing expert evidence in civil proceedings in England and Wales, the overriding duty is to assist the court. This takes precedence over obligations to the instructing party.

CPR Part 35: experts & assessors ↗

Instruction profile

Claimant, Defendant
& Joint instructions.

Claimant
50%
Defendant
40%
Joint
10%

The instruction split reflects the practice’s work across all three categories. Each opinion is independent of the instructing party.

Specialist scope

Areas of expertise.

Adult and paediatric cases involving nerve injury and complex upper limb orthopaedics. Suitability is assessed against the specific questions in each instruction.

Brachial plexus injury

Traumatic and birth-related injuries, their functional consequences and the implications for reconstruction and rehabilitation.

Traumatic peripheral nerve injury

Nerve injury associated with fractures, dislocations and other limb trauma, including assessment of delayed recognition or referral.

Nerve injury following treatment

Postoperative and procedure-related nerve injury, including positioning, venepuncture and nerve injury following hip replacement.

Nerve compression & nerve tumours

Entrapment neuropathies, thoracic outlet syndrome and nerve sheath tumours, with assessment of diagnosis, treatment and outcome.

Children & young people

Birth-related brachial plexus injury and peripheral nerve injury in children, including nerve injury following supracondylar fractures.

Complex upper limb conditions

Shoulder and elbow trauma, nerve and tendon reconstruction, persistent weakness and neuropathic pain affecting everyday function.

If a question falls outside Mr Simpson’s expertise, this will be identified when considering the instruction or reviewing the evidence.

Reports & services

The right opinion
for the question.

Instructions can address a defined issue or combine related questions. Breach of duty and causation may be considered separately from condition and prognosis where this assists the instruction.

Discuss the scope of a report
01Advisory opinionsAn initial review of the clinical issues and available evidence to help define the questions requiring expert opinion.

Useful when considering suitability for a full instruction, identifying additional evidence or clarifying the appropriate specialist scope.

Enquire about this service
02Breach of duty & causationAssessment of the care provided and the relationship between an alleged failing and the subsequent injury or outcome, within Mr Simpson’s area of expertise.

The analysis distinguishes the mechanism of injury, the standard of care and the outcome that would be expected in the relevant alternative circumstances. A complication alone does not establish negligence.

Enquire about this service
03Condition & prognosisAssessment of the injury, current symptoms, examination findings and functional consequences, with an opinion on recovery and future needs.

Reports can address daily activities, work, further treatment and prognosis. Examination and review of imaging or nerve tests are arranged according to the questions in the instruction.

Enquire about this service
04Supplementary reportsFurther opinion where new medical records, imaging, clinical developments or questions become available.

Additional evidence is considered in the context of the earlier opinion, with any resulting changes and remaining uncertainties explained.

Enquire about this service
05Conferences & expert discussionsDiscussion of the medical evidence with the instructing legal team, and participation in joint expert discussions where instructed.

The aim is to clarify the issues, explain the basis of the opinion and identify areas of agreement or disagreement. Please provide relevant conference and court deadlines at the outset.

Enquire about this service
06Desktop assessmentsDocument-based assessment where the questions can appropriately be addressed from the available records without a clinical examination.

The report identifies the evidence relied upon and the limitations of a desktop assessment. If an examination or another specialty is needed, this is made clear.

Enquire about this service

From enquiry to report

How to instruct.

Establish suitability, agree the scope and arrange the evidence required for an informed opinion.

  1. 01

    Outline the instruction

    Send an anonymised summary, the report or service required, the instructing party and any relevant deadlines.

  2. 02

    Confirm the arrangements

    Suitability, conflicts, availability, fees and terms are considered before acceptance. Agree secure transfer arrangements before providing confidential information.

  3. 03

    Provide the evidence

    Supply the letter of instruction and relevant records via a secure link or in a password-protected file, with the password sent separately. Where an examination is needed, confirm the preferred venue and attendance arrangements.

  4. 04

    Receive the opinion

    The report addresses the instructed questions and explains its reasoning, conclusions and limitations. Further questions or new evidence can be considered through a subsequent instruction.

Reports within 28 days

Of assessment, or receipt of documentation for a desktop report.

Working to a particular deadline?

Include it in the initial enquiry so availability can be confirmed before acceptance.

Preparing the instruction

The information
that helps.

A clear letter of instruction and well organised documentation help focus the opinion on the questions that matter.

For the initial enquiry, an anonymised outline is sufficient. Claimant identifiers, conflict-check information and confidential records should follow via an agreed secure link or in a password-protected file. Send the password separately from the file.

Start an instruction enquiry

Once arrangements are agreed

  • A letter of instruction setting out the questions, required report and relevant deadlines.
  • Relevant medical records, preferably indexed and paginated, including operation notes and follow-up documentation.
  • Relevant imaging and reports, and neurophysiology results where available.
  • The material claim documents and any existing expert evidence relevant to the instruction.
  • A chronology, details of subsequent treatment and any specific issues requiring clarification.
  • For an examination, information about attendance, accessibility, an interpreter or a parent or carer, where relevant.

Provide the evidence relevant to the instructed questions. Please identify any records or investigations that remain outstanding.

Practical arrangements

Plan the instruction.

Fees available on request.

Please request a quotation and terms when enquiring. The documentation, scope of questions and any examination or conference requirements inform the proposed arrangements.

Assessment locations.

RNOH Private Care – Stanmore
RNOH Private Care – Bolsover Street
Wimpole Street Consulting Rooms

Home visits are available when required. Assessments can also take place at a clinic organised by the instructing party.

Confirm the preferred venue when making an instruction enquiry. Desktop reports are available where appropriate.

Sending documentation.

Documents can be sent via a secure link or in a password-protected file. Please send the password separately from the file.

Confirm the transfer arrangements before sharing claimant identifiers, medical records, imaging or subsequent evidence.

New instructions

Discuss your
requirements.

Use the enquiry builder to prepare an email, or contact Simpson Medicolegal Services directly.

Keep the first enquiry brief.

Please use an anonymised outline. Do not include claimant names, dates of birth or medical records at this stage. After contact, documents can be sent via a secure link or in a password-protected file, with the password sent separately.

Looking for clinical care?

For assessment or treatment as a patient, book through London Nerve Injury.

Enquire by email

Include your name and firm, the type of matter, the report required, any deadline and a brief anonymised outline.

Open enquiry email

Your email application opens a template for you to review and send. Please request secure transfer arrangements before sharing confidential information.

Before you instruct

Common questions.

Practical guidance for solicitors and other instructing professionals.

Do you accept Claimant, Defendant and Joint instructions?

Yes. Mr Simpson accepts instructions from all three, subject to suitability, availability and conflict checks. The practice instruction split is 50% Claimant, 40% Defendant and 10% Joint. The opinion remains independent of the instructing party.

What is the report turnaround time?

Reports are provided within 28 days of assessment, or receipt of documentation for a desktop report. Please identify any court, conference or other required deadline when making the initial enquiry.

Can an opinion be provided without examining the Claimant?

A desktop report may be appropriate where the questions can be addressed from the available documentation. The need for an examination depends on the issues in the instruction. Limitations arising from the evidence or absence of examination are explained.

How are fees agreed?

Fees are available on request. The scope of work, documentation, examination requirements and relevant deadlines inform the proposed fee arrangements. Please request a quotation when enquiring; terms are agreed before work proceeds.

How should confidential records be supplied?

Documents can be sent via a secure link or in a password-protected file. Please send the password separately from the file. The initial enquiry should contain an anonymised outline only. Confirm the transfer arrangements with Simpson Medicolegal Services before providing claimant identifiers, medical records or imaging.

Where can medicolegal assessments take place?

Assessments can take place at RNOH Private Care – Stanmore, RNOH Private Care – Bolsover Street, or Wimpole Street Consulting Rooms. Home visits are available when required, and assessments can also take place at a clinic organised by the instructing party. Arrange assessments through Simpson Medicolegal Services and confirm the venue when instructing. The clinical appointment calendars on London Nerve Injury are for patient consultations.

Can I request an urgent report or a conference?

Please state the required date and nature of the work in your enquiry. Availability and the ability to meet a particular deadline must be confirmed before the instruction is accepted.

Instruction enquiryHow to instruct